Every single one of them is at home. I know this before I even get to the checkout line. There’s a moment in every grocery trip — usually right around the pasta aisle — where I remember the bags exist, do a quick mental audit of where they are (home, car, no wait still home), and make the private decision to simply not think about it until it’s too late. Then it’s too late. Then I buy another one.
The bags accumulate like a symptom. I have the sturdy ones from Trader Joe’s, the flimsy ones from every other grocery store, the tote bags from bookshops, the ones with logos from companies I don’t remember interacting with, a canvas one that says something in French, two that came free with a magazine subscription I cancelled in 2021. None of them have ever been in my car at the same time as groceries.
The system fails at a very specific point: the transfer. You unpack the bags after shopping, put the food away, and then the bags just sit there on the counter looking used and slightly sad. At some point you move them to a chair. Then a drawer. Then a closet shelf that is specifically for bags now. Then you leave for the store without them. The cycle is airtight.
I’ve tried the thing where you put them straight back in the car after unpacking. It worked twice. On the third time I was in a hurry and now there are two bags in my car and thirty-eight in the house and I still bought plastic bags last week because I forgot the two were in the car.
What I find hard to accept is that this is apparently just who I am. I care about the environment in a general, sincere way. I think about the future. I compost sometimes. And yet there is a gap between the person I am at home, surrounded by bags, and the person I am at the grocery store, bagless and slightly guilty, that no amount of intention has been able to close.
I bought another bag today. It’s a good one. Very sturdy. It’s on my kitchen counter right now.